XGames

  • All Sports
    • Skateboarding
    • Snowboarding
    • Surfing
    • Skiing
    • BMX
    • Rally/Moto X
  • Events
  • Photos & Videos
  • Athletes
  • Scene
ESPN
EnglishX
  • English
  • Portuguese
  • Spanish
  • German
  • Catalan
  • French

Barcelona '13 - Spain May 16-19

  • Top Video
  • Schedule
  • Red Bull Phenom
  • Results
  • Real Women
  • HypeMeter
  • Pro Series
Save the Date X Games Barcelona 2013: May 16-19
cSkiing
    • more Skiing
    • 1V

      Part 4: Behind The Lens

      Cameras roll, avalanches happen. But it's what goes on behind the scenes that counts
    • 2V

      Litigation involving inbounds avalanche fatalities on the rise in the U.S.

      Litigation involving inbounds avalanche fatalities on the rise
    Share:
    • Z

      Subscribe to Channels

      Follow the latest videos of your favorite sport. Just click buttons on any sport.

      • Z
        BMX
      • Z
        Skateboarding
      • Z
        Surfing
      • Z
        Freeskiing
      • Z
        Snowboarding
      • Z
        Rally/Moto X
    • E
    • C
    • e
      • Pin It
      • Google+
      • Email
      Embed
    RVdA

    The human factor

    By Griffin Post

    Published Monday November 19, 2012


    Home Intro Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Part 5 Part 6

    I was 16 when I was caught in my first avalanche.

    It was April at Mammoth Mountain, Calif., and it had been snowing hard enough to cancel the giant slalom race I was there for. The storm had dumped several feet of snow since we'd been there, and with the day now free, I headed out for some powder skiing with friends. The snow was deep and light and we lapped a lower lift nonstop, bobbing through trees and coughing on powder.

    "The basic thing we're talking about is helping the group realize they're doing something without thinking about it."Margaret Wheeler, AIARE instructor

    After several laps in a steep, wooded zone, we decided to push farther left into a pristine, untracked bowl that funneled into a narrow chute. Green as I was in terms of avalanche education, I hesitated on the drop-in, suspicious of why it was untracked. As I contemplated, an older skier slid up next to me, beard caked in snow.

    "What do you think?" I asked sheepishly.

    "Sometimes you just got to go for it," he responded.

    With all the confirmation I needed, I flashed a wan smile through braces and pushed off into the blank canvas. I made only one turn before I heard the whoomp, the first note of the avalanche symphony.

    The slope cracked under me, like a spider web from ridge to ridge, and I started sliding. In a moment of panic, I made a lunge for a small group of trees, the only anchor on the slope. They were small but spry, and I managed to self-arrest before I was carried through the choke and into the forest below. Heart racing, jacket full of snow, I looked around. The stranger was gone, and I was alone -- but OK -- on the freshly cleared slope.

    Truth be told, after years of avalanche education, building snow pits, and copious amounts of discussion, there's a decent chance -- if the opportunity presented itself -- I'd make the same decision to ski that slope tomorrow. Because even though most of the red flags -- new snow, wind, increasing temperature, cracking and recent avalanches -- were present, so was the one thing that can override them: the human factor.

    Mark FisherThe author, pro skier Griffin Post.
    Ian McCammon is an avalanche researcher based in Salt Lake City, Utah, who investigates the role that the human factor, or unconscious rules of thumb, play in backcountry decision-making.

    To provide a window into this most complicated element of backcountry education, McCammon, in a paper called "Heuristic Traps in Recreational Avalanche Accidents: Evidence and Implications," investigates six pitfalls that stem from experience -- familiarity, consistency, acceptance, the expert halo, social facilitation and scarcity -- in the context of the backcountry.

    By studying 715 documented recreational avalanche incidents over 31 years, McCammon sought to determine how the mental guidelines used in everyday life can betray travelers in the backcountry.

    Heuristics, or the experience-based problem-solving techniques used in everyday life, become dubious in avalanche terrain due to the unique factors presented by the backcountry setting and group dynamics.

    At Mammoth, I fell into two of these traps: scarcity (my desire for access to an untracked slope) and social facilitation (engaging in risky activity due to the presence of another person).

    The other traps that were absent were: familiarity, or perceiving an activity to be safe because it has been safe in the past; consistency, or maintaining the course based on an initial decision, even given new information; the expert halo, or crediting a leader with more knowledge than he is due and allowing him to make the decisions; and acceptance, or engaging in an activity we think will get us noticed or accepted by people we like or respect.

    Though McCammon's research has been out for nearly a decade, avalanche educators are still struggling to instill this knowledge in their students. "Traditionally, avalanche education focused on external conditions -- the snowpack, weak layers, stability tests, terrain -- things [that have] tools to measure," says McCammon. "But when it comes to human factors, the topic is a lot more fuzzy. It's difficult to quantify those variables, [and] humans are notoriously bad at self-assessment."

    Megan MichelsonAvalanche safety courses are a must for anyone looking to venture into backcountry terrain.
    While educators undoubtedly have their work cut out for them, these complex psychological factors are exactly what they have their sights set on. "McCammon and others have come up with this idea that, wait a minute, 'We are the problem out there. It's not the avalanches,'" says avalanche educator and guide Kent Scheler. "The new progression of education is based around humans -- how we handle stress, peer pressure and these heuristic traps that have been identified."

    Scheler says that every avalanche course today focuses not only on what makes a slab avalanche but also on the decision-making process involved with being in avalanche terrain. But as avalanche educators like to note, teaching the human factor is one thing; having students implement their knowledge in the field is another.

    "There's not a lot of evidence [to prove that] teaching people about human factors improves their decision-making -- not just in avalanche training, but for emergency doctors, people in combat situations or fire commanders," says McCammon.

    Close
    • 1null

      Avy Safety 101

      Megan Michelson

      At a recent avalanche safety course in Tahoe City, Calif., a group of female pro skiers gathered to refresh its skills and knowledge of backcountry safety before the winter comes.

    • 2null

      Teacher Tone

      Megan Michelson

      Lel Tone -- a Squaw Valley ski patroller, Alaskan heli ski guide and instructor with the American Institute for Avalanche Research and Education -- taught the course.

    • 3null

      The Books

      Megan Michelson

      Avalanche education has changed over the past decade to focus more on teaching people to recognize the human factors that play into the decision-making process along with the snow conditions, terrain and more.

    • 4null

      Checklist

      Megan Michelson

      Skier Amie Engerbretson practices using a checklist to walk through the steps of an avalanche rescue.

    • 5null

      Red Means No Go

      Megan Michelson

      A checklist helps backcountry skiers and snowboarders make smart decisions as to whether they're heading into safe terrain.

    • 6null

      Elyse Saugstad

      Megan Michelson

      Pro skier Elyse Saugstad, who survived a deadly avalanche last winter, practices using her beacon, shovel and probe in a rescue scenario.

    • 7null

      Ingrid Backstrom

      Megan Michelson

      Pro skier Ingrid Backstrom works with instructor Lel Tone to identify the search directions on her avalanche transceiver.

    • 8null

      Michelle Parker

      Megan Michelson

      Michelle Parker, with help from Lel Tone, practices probing for a buried victim during a pretend rescue scenario.

    • 9null

      Practice Makes Perfect

      Megan Michelson

      Ingrid Backstrom and Jackie Paaso rehearse the steps of an avalanche rescue.

    • 10null

      Beacon Search

      Megan Michelson

      Sherry McConkey, Michelle Parker and Ingrid Backstrom zone in on a buried signal during a practice rescue.

    • 11null

      Airbag Pack

      Megan Michelson

      Amie Engerbretson, Sherry McConkey and Michelle Parker practice using a BCA airbag backpack.

    a
    a
    a
    H
    • 1null

      Avy Safety 101

      At a recent avalanche safety course in Tahoe City, Calif., a group of female pro skiers gathered to refresh its skills and knowledge of backcountry safety before the winter comes.
    • 2null

      Teacher Tone

      Lel Tone -- a Squaw Valley ski patroller, Alaskan heli ski guide and instructor with the American Institute for Avalanche Research and Education -- taught the course.
    • 3null

      The Books

      Avalanche education has changed over the past decade to focus more on teaching people to recognize the human factors that play into the decision-making process along with the snow conditions, terrain and more.
    • 4null

      Checklist

      Skier Amie Engerbretson practices using a checklist to walk through the steps of an avalanche rescue.
    • 5null

      Red Means No Go

      A checklist helps backcountry skiers and snowboarders make smart decisions as to whether they're heading into safe terrain.
    • 6null

      Elyse Saugstad

      Pro skier Elyse Saugstad, who survived a deadly avalanche last winter, practices using her beacon, shovel and probe in a rescue scenario.
    • 7null

      Ingrid Backstrom

      Pro skier Ingrid Backstrom works with instructor Lel Tone to identify the search directions on her avalanche transceiver.
    • 8null

      Michelle Parker

      Michelle Parker, with help from Lel Tone, practices probing for a buried victim during a pretend rescue scenario.
    • 9null

      Practice Makes Perfect

      Ingrid Backstrom and Jackie Paaso rehearse the steps of an avalanche rescue.
    • 10null

      Beacon Search

      Sherry McConkey, Michelle Parker and Ingrid Backstrom zone in on a buried signal during a practice rescue.
    • 11null

      Airbag Pack

      Amie Engerbretson, Sherry McConkey and Michelle Parker practice using a BCA airbag backpack.

    Still, instructor Margaret Wheeler and her colleagues at the American Institute for Avalanche Rescue and Education (AIARE) -- the nationally recognized and foremost avalanche-education organization in the U.S. -- are set on creating ways to navigate the human factor in the oft-chaotic backcountry setting.

    While Wheeler acknowledges the limitations of real-time self-critiquing in the backcountry, she believes the answer lies in empowering students with a checklist and discussion tools that allow them to constantly keep tabs on the state of the group.

    "The basic thing we're talking about is helping the group realize they're doing something without thinking about it," says Wheeler, also a member of the American Mountain Guides Association board of directors.

    Megan MichelsonA hazard checklist that avalanche educators are working to instill in their students.

    On the AIARE-developed checklist are two human-based protocol: having a facilitator and having a group consensus. The facilitator serves as the catalyst for conversation about decision-making throughout the day as conditions, moods and risk change. While facilitators are central to the checklist, they are effective only if the group can agree on the goals for the day.

    "We haven't solved it yet. We've been testing this checklist in our own backcountry groups, and our goal is to have people see themselves as a facilitator," says Wheeler.

    Just as snow science will never be perfect or 100 percent predictable, the human equation will never be fully "solved." But it's through this ongoing quest for understanding that risks can be mitigated and, ultimately, lives can be saved.

    However, nothing is foolproof, Wheeler contends. "Whatever system we design to manage it, we ourselves will find a way to game that system."

    Because that's just human nature.

    Heading into the backcountry? Find an avalanche education course near you at Avalanche.org.

    dRelated

    • 1J

      Spring Training

      U.S. Freeskiing and Snowboarding teams gather for a spring training camp at Mammoth Mountain, Calif.
    • 2R

      Behind Real Women ~ Michelle Parker

      Go behind the scenes of the making of Michelle Parker's X Games Real Women 2013 video contest entry.
    • 3R

      Behind Real Women ~ Ingrid Backstrom

      Go behind the scenes of the making of Ingrid Backstrom's X Games Real Women 2013 video contest entry.
    • 4R

      Sammy Carlson

      Sammy Carlson on filming his winning X Games Real Ski Backcountry part
    • 5J

      X Games meets the Olympics

      X Games meets the Olympics
    • 6R

      Adam Delorme at Mammoth

      "This is Adam Delorme skiing how he rides - fast, flexing hard, and buttering his skis. It's a minimal rotation trick yet there is no one else who can do it quite like him." -Tom Wallisch

    Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, photo & other personal information you make public on Facebook will appear with your comment, and may be used on ESPN’s media platforms. Learn more

a
H
My ChannelsNew
Site Terms

FOLLOW US

E
Facebook
C
Twitter
M
Google +
youtube
youtube
Follow
    Y
    Follow

    Follow the latest videos of your favorite sport. Just click buttons on any sport

    FOLLOW CHANNELS

    Use this menu to customize your viewing experience. Once you follow a sport, the newest videos will always be waiting for you in this menu.

    BMX

    Znot followed

    Skateboarding

    Znot followed

    Snowboarding

    Znot followed

    Skiing

    Znot followed

    Rally/Moto X

    Znot followed

    Surfing

    Znot followed
    ESPN.com: Help | Press | Advertise on ESPN.com | Sales Media Kit | Interest-Based Ads | Corrections | Contact Us | Site Map | Patents | Jobs at ESPN | Supplier Information
    ©2013 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information/Your California Privacy Rights are applicable to you. All rights reserved.